Log In
Register
Home
Topic RSS
9:25 am
February 24, 2010
Offline
Mary Boleyn's children – Catherine Carey & Henry Carey. Because Henry never claimed these two as his, there is a question as to whether they were his. Both birth dates, however, fall within the time period of the relationship with Henry.
Eliabeth Blount's child by Henry – Henry Fitzroy. Claimed by Henry. Named Duke of Richmond.
Katherine of Aragon – Mary. They also had a son Henry who lived a few weeks. Without looking this up I can't be certain, but if memory serves, she had seven pregnancies.
And of course Anne – Elizabeth
Jane – Edward
No more that I recall.
2:50 pm
March 12, 2010
Offline
Has anyone read the book on the review page called “The Other Tudors” by Philippa Jones? In her review, Claire says PJ mentions mistresses and children that she had never heard associated with Henry before. I'd like to read it just because.
9:01 pm
April 20, 2010
Offline
I have to believe that it was more than is documented…..he seemed very amorous! And I’ve read that he had affairs with some “ladies of the court”…..
If that is true, and those ladies conceived, I know if I were them(back then), I would have kept my mouth shut and went to the country to have and raise my child in peace…..no one would ever know that Henry was the father……and I’d be honest with my husband(most husbands probably didn’t mind the affair with the king anyway…they probably got a block of land out of it)…..
And yes, I believe that he fathered Mary Boleyn’s children, although why he wouldn’t ackowledge them is a mystery..unless it would have messed up his marriage plans to Anne(too close)…….because if he had a long relationship and no baby resulted, that would have been odd and I think worth mentioning….
9:40 am
June 19, 2009
Offline
“The other Tudors” is a very interesting and frank book. It looks at all the reported offspring and the suspected ones too. It looks at them in a methodical way, showing where some were possible and some were not. Many of Henry's “Lovers” were married women, so having male children with them was not really useful as to claim them would provoke the wrath of the church in Rome. There is an interesting point made though, if Henry was the father of Mary Carey's (Boleyn) children, if one follows the bloodline, we find people like Winston Churchill and Lady Diana Spencer, who later became Princess Diana and mother to Princes Harry and William. Now, if one of the princes were to become King someday….?
Interesting!
If it was not this, then it would be something else?
4:15 pm
January 9, 2010
Offline
I haven't read 'The Other Tudors' yet. It seems to have been sitting in my to-read pile (small mountain, really!) since forever, so one of these days I'll get round to it! I didn't realise that Princess Diana was a descendant of Mary Boleyn, thanks for pointing that out ipaud! Strange indeed to think we could have another Boleyn descendant as king!
*runs off to flick through 'The Other Tudors!*
7:14 am
March 12, 2010
Offline
Wow I didn't know that either. That would be great if he kept up the tradition like you said, wreckmasterjay! I definitely want to read that book at some point too.
4:05 pm
November 18, 2010
Offline
ipaud said:
“The other Tudors” is a very interesting and frank book. It looks at all the reported offspring and the suspected ones too. It looks at them in a methodical way, showing where some were possible and some were not. Many of Henry's “Lovers” were married women, so having male children with them was not really useful as to claim them would provoke the wrath of the church in Rome. There is an interesting point made though, if Henry was the father of Mary Carey's (Boleyn) children, if one follows the bloodline, we find people like Winston Churchill and Lady Diana Spencer, who later became Princess Diana and mother to Princes Harry and William. Now, if one of the princes were to become King someday….?
Interesting!
Since another of her desendants was Elizabeth Bowes-Lyons, her blood-line already is on the throne.
It's always bunnies.
5:59 pm
August 2, 2010
Offline
What is everyone's opinion about Mary Carey's two children? I'm not sure, but I read somewhere that one of them (for the life of me I can't remember which!!) looked extraordinarily like Henry. Also that one of them was born in a more plausible time than the other. Unfortunately both Mary's husband and Henry had similar coloring, so on that front it's a bit hard to tell. An argument for them being Henry's children is that would Henry have wanted to “share” Mary with Carey? I don't think so. The argument against it…well, Henry had difficulty begetting children, didn't he? I suppose to me it doesn't seem all that likely that he ended up with two healthy children from Mary. Perhaps one??
"Grumble all you like, this is how it's going to be"
9:45 pm
October 31, 2010
Offline
I think it's pretty clear that Henry had some fertility issues (low sperm count maybe?). And I think it's pretty clear that KoA must have also had some sort of gynecological problems–we know that Mary certainly did, and it would make sense if she inherited that from her mother. This I'm sure explains KoA's difficulty in having healthy children.
I think Henry's fertility was less of a problem pre-Anne Boleyn so it might be possible for one of Mary Boleyn's children to be Henry's. I certainly think it's more PROBABLE that one of Mary's children was Henry's since he was younger during that relationship and, thus, less likely to be suffering from more severe infertility issues. We certainly know that by the time he married Anne that he had started to suffer from periodic bouts of impotence. I firmly believe that Anne's difficulty in maintaining a pregnancy stemmed more from Henry than from herself, though, Anne was no spring chicken once she finally married and began having children.
Of course, the finer points of fertility were far from understood in those days.
"We mustn't let our passions destroy our dreams…"
9:50 pm
October 31, 2010
Offline
Not to mention that, by this point, Europe's royal houses were starting to get pretty in-bred which is NEVER a good thing when it comes to human genomes…or any genomes, really, for that matter. Perhaps the mere fact that Mary Boleyn was NOT royalty and was introducing some new genes into the pool could have given her an edge…
"We mustn't let our passions destroy our dreams…"
1:19 pm
February 24, 2010
Offline
I tend to think that Henry Boleyn was Henry's child. Of course we can't know for sure. I wish we could do a DNA test to find out. Catherine is the older of the two. Henry is the one they said looked just like the king. At this time in Henry's life he didn't seem to have a problem making babies. His wife, Katherine couldn't carry them to term. Elizabeth Blount had given him a son (1519) after Henry's daughter Mary was born. (1516) In his book, Six Wives, David Starkey says, when Henry's lovers gave birth, it was the beginning of the end of their relationship. After Richmond was born, Henry ended his alliance with Elizabeth Blount. After Henry was born, the king ended his relationship with Mary Boleyn. He doesn't seem to think Catherine was Henry's. I'm not so sure. She seems to have been born in the middle of the affair. oooo…it's frustrating not knowing for sure.
4:29 pm
August 2, 2010
Offline
If everyone had to guess, who would you think his chidlren were?
"Grumble all you like, this is how it's going to be"
2:46 pm
December 22, 2010
Offline
Well lets take this by wife:
Catherine of Aragon: 6, Henry, born January 1, 1511, died on February 22, 1511, Stillborn son born November, 1513,
Stillborn son born December 14, 1514, Stillborn daughter born January 10, 1510, Stillborn daughter
born November 10, 1518 and Mary, born February 18, 1516.
Anne Boleyn: 2, Elizabeth, born September 7, 1533, Stillborn son born January 29, 1536
Jane Seymour: 1, Edward born October 12, 1537
Anne of Cleaves: 0
Katherine Howard 0
Catherine Parr 0
Bessie Blount 1, Henry Fitzroy, born in 1519
Mary Boleyn 1, Catherine, born 1520?
Total 11 children were born with King Henry VIII as their father is my answer to this question.
7:05 am
August 2, 2010
Offline
What about Mary Boleyn's other child, Henry?
"Grumble all you like, this is how it's going to be"
7:05 am
January 3, 2011
Offline
Almost – Henry fathered two children with Mary Boleyn
1. Catherine
2. Henry (later known as Henry Hunsdon.
I am new, nice to be here.
4:23 pm
November 18, 2010
Offline
In Alison weir's genealogy Britain's Royal Families she lists the following issue.
By Catherine of Aragon
1 stillborn daughter 31/1/1510
2 Henry Duke of Cornwall Jan 1-22 Feb 1511
3 unnnamed son November 1513
4 Unnamed son Feb 1515
5 Mary 18/2/1516-17/11/1558
6 Unnamed daughter 10/11/1518
By Anne Boleyn
1 Elizabeth 7/9/1533-24/3/1603
2 stillborn child? Aug or Sept 1534
3 stillborn son 29/1/1536
By Jane Seymour
Eward 12/10/1537-6/7/1553
No issue from other marriages.
Illegimate children
By Bessie Blount
Henry Fitzroy 1519-1536
By Joan Dobson( or Dingley)
Elthelreda ( or Audrey) ?-1555
2 other names are mentioned as being unlikely to be Henry's
Sir John Perrot
Thomas Stucley(or Stukley)
She doesn't mention Mary Boleyn's childrenin the genealogy. Though in her The Six Wives of Henry VIII , she mantions that Henry's lack of acknowledge should be taken as that the children were not his but those of William Carey.
It's always bunnies.
6:12 am
January 3, 2011
Offline
http://www.genealogymagazine.c…..oleyn.html
Hi, thanks for the llist, I am familiar with Ms Weirs work – and have enjoyed it, Have a look at the information on the above link. Primary sources can be helpful.
Its interesting to consider that Henry Hunsdon (Carey) was, by some, considered to be Henry VIII's natural son. Goodness knows how many others were born on the wrong side of he covers?
Ultimately, its all conjecture because supposition, suspicion and rumours are just that.
10:22 pm
November 18, 2010
Offline
cwen said:
http://www.genealogymagazine.c…..oleyn.html
Hi, thanks for the llist, I am familiar with Ms Weirs work – and have enjoyed it, Have a look at the information on the above link. Primary sources can be helpful.
Its interesting to consider that Henry Hunsdon (Carey) was, by some, considered to be Henry VIII's natural son. Goodness knows how many others were born on the wrong side of he covers?
Ultimately, its all conjecture because supposition, suspicion and rumours are just that.
http://www.theanneboleynfiles……men/#p5672
I've cross posted your link into this thread since we are talking about Mary's children there.
It's always bunnies.
4:01 am
March 20, 2011
Offline
wreckmasterjay said:
Just wondering with all the affairs and mistresses he had…..just how many children did he have?
Catherine of Aragon – Mary (plus 3 stillborn i think?)
Anne Boleyn – Elizabeth (plus 3 stillborn)
Jane Seymour – Edward
Mary Boleyn – 2 ?
Elizabeth Blount – 1 ?
Any more you can think of? I'll be honest, I cant remember the names given to Mary Boleyn's and Lady Blounts children.
These are just my thoughts:
Catherine of Aragon: Mary and a whole lot of stillborn babies
Anne Boleyn: Elizabeth and two stillborn babies
Jane Seymour: Edward
Mary Boleyn: 2
Elizabeth Blount:1
Henry was a womanizer, so he probably had issue here and there in England….
8:09 am
February 24, 2010
Offline
A previous post asks why Henry would not have acknowldged Mary's children. Assuming as I do that they were Henry's, I'm thinking that it was because Mary had a husband and there was no way to prove whose children they were. Bessie Blount did not marry until 1522. Henry Fitzroy was born in 1519. Henry could claim him as his because there was no husband to gainsay him.
